Here is a story that might interest you. A few years ago, Herbert Wigwe, the CEO of Access Holdings, lost his life in a tragic helicopter accident. Before his death, it was said that he worshipped at RCCG City of David. A few weeks after his death, the wife of the church’s head pastor, Dr Mrs Siju Iluyomade, held a birthday party at Eko Hotel and Suites. The party, from what we hear, was incredible. Not only was it lavish, it also had many friends of Wigwe and high-ranking members of the church having a fantastically good time. To crown their efforts, they hired Flavour to perform at the event. This all happened before Wigwe had even been buried.

Now, I don’t know what you might think about these things, but if I died in a tragic way — cut short in the prime of my life, after being a blessing to my church — I would be really mad if I noticed the people I was such a blessing to dancing their sorrows away at some party before I was even in the ground. The Nigerian public (the ones who cared about these things anyway) were beyond outraged. It didn’t look good at all, and someone even compared Doctor Mrs to some fellow from the French Revolution.

In response, the Wigwe family held the funeral at another church, and senior members of the City of David family were conspicuously absent. The RCCG headquarters didn’t take the issue with levity either, and four months later, Pastor Iluyomade found himself suspended for three months. This was extremely disgraceful, and is ordinarily something you would imagine a head pastor of such a prestigious church couldn’t come back from. How seriously would you take lessons on humility and decorum from your pastor who was suspended for being a naughty party boy?

But the worst was still to come. After his suspension, Pastor Iluyomade expected to be welcomed back to church, but he was given a letter barring him from the church premises. The pastor then founded The Family Fellowship, with an inaugural service at the Civic Centre, Victoria Island. The game is the game, as they say.

This story, at the time, appeared like some comical evil Dostoevsky might write about. How evil is that, you may wonder. How heartless, how — you might even reach for this word — dystopian is that! Would Jesus really sanction church hopping because of a suspension? Or is this one of God’s mysterious ways?

But now that I am older (and poorer) than I was, I understand Pastor Iluyomade perfectly. What was the good pastor to do? If you get fired from your cushy job, would you sit at home all day and cry about your life? No, you wouldn’t. Would any serious person expect any family man to do that?

I Think God Doesn’t Like Me Writing These Articles

The first Sunday I planned my City of David visit was a mess. I somehow got into a bus that broke down in the middle of Third Mainland Bridge. To make things worse, just as I was about to get down and maybe flag another bus, rain started falling heavily. It gets worse, if you can believe it.

The driver didn’t actually own the bus, and was something of a broke bum, so he couldn’t even pay to tow the vehicle. He begged the tow truck, our only hope of leaving the bridge, for one solid hour to tow it for free. Once the truck took us onto the island, the driver told us to get down as he wanted to check something. Then he got back into the bus and asked the tow truck to go on, leaving us wet and under the bridge.

I had no choice but to trek to Obalende in the rain, after which I waited for an hour in a small bus before we got moving. By the time I arrived at the church, the service was done. If you believe in signs and things like that, all of this probably means I should not overshoot my station and talk candidly about a church. One may even say it is God’s way of telling me to turn back.

But again, during my time at LOGIC Church I learnt this sort of thinking is stupid, actually. So, the beatings will continue. Hopefully, morale improves.

We Are the Wealthiest Church in Nigeria

“When I used to go there for special programmes for RCCG churches in Lagos, they used to boast that they are the wealthiest church in the country. I don’t know if they still do that.”


City of David is, well, very appropriately named. It’s basically a fortress. The church is a 14 storey tower with an auditorium that holds 4500 people. It cost more than 12 billion naira to build it, and contains commercial spaces that the church rents out. As far as church buildings go, this is quite impressive. It is all the more impressive because City of David is merely one of the many Redeemed churches in the country.
But how is City of David so wealthy? Well, the answer lies in its members. The church is situated on prime Victoria Island real estate, and as you would expect, very wealthy people live in this area. Some of these wealthy people are members of the church, and they must have, no doubt, contributed to the status of the church.
Now, I have been to many churches on this journey, but none quite as opulent as City of David. While many other churches had glitz and glamour to cover up the screaming A/C and badly damaged tent, you get the sense that City of David was authentically wealthy. The lobby feels like a bank; there is central air conditioning, and there is an elevator and an escalator. The screen didn’t have any of those botched gaps you get in we-are-still-begging-God ministries, and they used an actual grand piano. The seats were the type you could get at a movie theatre, and everything seemed so luxurious (according to the Nigerian understanding of the term).

Given the fantastic ambience of the church, and the billions of naira used in building up the edifice, you would expect a masterpiece of a sermon. But the gospel is simple, and at City of David they make it even simpler so that your transactional Nigerian head can understand the business. And this is serious business.

Here Is the Gospel, If You Can Believe It

Over the four Sundays that I visited, and the different pastors that I listened to, one theme emerged: God doesn’t cheat. El Shaddai always pays his debts. 

Here is how a sermon may go:The pastor begins speaking about how horrible the world is now, and how you need something extraordinary to get ahead. That thing doesn’t have a name, really. On one Sunday it might be faith, on another it might be power, and you may even hear someone call it a discerning eye.

The big issue is how we get this thing so that we can get ahead in this life. The solution, the pastors say, is simple. You only need to surrender your life, become a Christian, stay away from sin, and you will get ahead. After all, didn’t the Bible say, ‘Seek ye first the kingdom of heaven and everything else will be added unto you’? That is as good a contract as any you are going to get on the matter. So, deal or no deal?

It is as good a deal as you will ever get in this bitch of a life, and it’s no surprise that many people take it. However, paying serious attention to the deal ends up revealing a sort of scam. You see, even if you do seek first the kingdom of God, this is no guarantee of your eventual success or everything-added-on-to-you-bility. Sometimes you have to engage in a bit of battle strategy, as we all know life is a battleground.

For instance, if you prayed to God for something today, you may not get it because you don’t yet deserve it. The pastor gives us an analogy of a young boy asking for a hundred-dollar bill from his father (what a queer example — why is this father not giving out naira? Our currency is too wretched for the house of God? Force of habit?) and not getting it. The father doesn’t refuse his son because he hates his son, but because the money might get stolen from his son. Therefore, the man, in his infinite (and certainly not miserly) wisdom, merely saves the money for the child till he gets older and can fight much better.

The thing you will notice about this analogy is that it is wrong even on its own terms. What serious man would deny a child what they need because it might get stolen? That is the story parents give their kids, but surely we must know that the real reason is because they do not think the child needs it, or because they cannot afford it. Now, I am willing to admit that so many people pray amiss, but this is a different issue from telling me I have to become a soldier to get what I am asking for.

The second problem with the analogy is that it disrupts the terms of the actual deal, which argues that I can get every other thing I want as long as I put God first. I am not told that God has to sign off on my receivables. Doesn’t this sound a bit scammy to you? It does to me!

But the caveats don’t end there. Sometimes you may not even get your receivables on time because God is actually fighting your battles for you. “Sometimes God’s delaying isn’t inability, it is strategy,” the pastor says on one Sunday. So, not only do I have to do everything right, I also have to be a fighter, and sometimes even my fighting isn’t enough, I have to defer to God’s strategy. Why would anyone sign this contract?

Well, there are two choices, implies the pastor. Stay in sin and suffer, or come to God and maybe (if God wills it) you may suffer less. And his evidence is, well, let me show you. Proverbs 28:13;

‘No one who conceals transgressions will prosper, but one who confesses and forsakes them will obtain mercy.’

I suppose the word prosper does sound like prosperity, and prosperity sounds like dollars, so I can understand it on that note. However, I don’t believe this is particularly convincing, especially as my previous church was The LOGIC Church. At least try to convince me to sign this contract with a bit more gravitas. What is the Latin word for prosper? The Greek word?

There are even more problems from the evidence of our eyes. We don’t know (and cannot know) the non-prospering rate (NPR) of transgression coverers for the simple fact that we do not know them. It is totally possible that covering your transgressions makes you more likely to prosper! In fact, from the evidence of Nigeria, where the most successful people seem to be the most morally bankrupt, it is likely that this is true.

However, the pastor has some evidence to refute this point. Mark 2:9

‘Which is easier, to say to the paralytic; your sins are forgiven, or to say “stand up and take your mat and walk?”’

At this point, I concede because of how miserly I am. How glad am I to discover that the invalids who beg for money on the street corner deserve to be there because of their sins! Now, I no longer feel guilty when I see them in their pitiful state while planning my next luxury purchase. I only wonder what dreadful sin they committed to be punished so! At least I now have no reason to give them any money. Praise Jesus!

There is even more evidence to totally annihilate my point. Hebrews 11:6

And without faith it is impossible to please God, because anyone who comes to him must believe that he exists and that he rewards those who earnestly seek him.

I suppose reward sounds like prosper which sounds like prosperity which sounds like dollars. Besides, Romans 3:23 says this;

‘for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God,’

Doesn’t glory sound a bit like reward?

How Much Should You Give as Offering?

When offering time came around, around 8 account numbers flashed on the screen. There was an account for every currency, and the church was raising around 2.1 billion naira for something. The numbers looked so big in front of me. 2.1 billion naira? I looked back at my account and wondered about the fairness of giving even a single kobo to this church. In fact, I am supposed to be collecting.

However, every serious Christian knows the truth; we don’t give because God has a need, but because we want to honour God. Given this, how much do you think honouring God is worth? 200 naira? Really? 500? One thousand? Or is there a fraction to it? Is 1% of your income enough? How about 20% of your income? 50%? 100%?

It’s hard to put a price to it. Because even all the money you have and all your income wouldn’t be enough. Not just that, it wouldn’t even be close to enough. But if something is priceless, and if a higher amount means absolutely nothing, what harm is in giving the lowest possible amount?

This logic may sound ridiculous to you, but that is the exact outcome of trying to minimize the value of one’s offering. If it’s truly the thought that counts, and there is no need to be met, why not accompany the biggest thought with the lowest naira denomination?

Rich Servants, Poor Congregants

Big Nigerian churches are some of the only places poor Nigerians and the mega rich can sit under one roof. The contrast, as you may expect, is often ridiculous. On your right side may be a billionaire, and on your left may be someone who hasn’t eaten a proper meal in weeks.

City of David somehow solves this problem by making their best-dressed and (certainly from my perspective) wealthiest members servants in the church. At the Lord’s Chosen, I noticed that the ushers were quite badly dressed. Some looked like they had just rolled out of bed after a weekend of binge drinking. Others looked like they had robbed an Aboki’s bag of rubbish for a coat too small and a shoe too big. That wasn’t the case at City of David.

The ushers wore the best suits you have ever seen in your life, and there was even a white man amongst them. Imagine that! A white man ushering you to your seat in the heart of Lagos. What is this, reverse 1960?

In any case, I found this very interesting. You could see that the workers were decidedly wealthier than the congregants, a dynamic that I wouldn’t have guessed. But why is this so? Allow me to dip into the worst parts of my mind for an answer. What if so many wealthy and accomplished people become workers because the sermon is so boring and they would rather walk around and do something than listen to a snoozefest for forty minutes?

The Sermons Are Boring, but Maybe That Is What Old People Like

Is that outrageous? Because I have even more outrageous things to note. It wasn’t merely boring, but scattered. Consider how much this essay jumps around from place to place, and imagine it translated into a sermon. That is exactly how every single pastor sounded.

On the fourth Sunday, it frankly got embarrassing, and I started wondering maybe it was a demographic difference. Maybe older Nigerians just prefer incoherent sermons interjected with personal experiences and testimonies. The last time I was subjected to a string of sermons of such low quality was at The Lord’s Chosen where Rev Maduka droned on for an hour without a head or a tail.

During every sermon, I could catch one or two persons enjoying the central air conditioning and just having a nap. This could never happen in LOGIC church or Harvesters or CCI or even Christ Embassy. One would expect the wealthiest Redeemed church in the country to have a better service on offer, but the sermons were a disappointment from a quality point of view.

What made this more interesting was the demographic. Almost every other person was above forty, and you got the real sense that the church was aging out. This was in great contrast with my experience at other churches like Christ Embassy and Harvesters where a bulk of the population was young people. Worse still was the fact that the church was never actually filled up. The upper floor was 90% empty every Sunday, and if this were a business, you may argue that there was a serious growth and customer retention problem just hovering on the horizon.

Is this the sort of sermons older accomplished Nigerians like? Or can it just not be helped? Or, worse still, is this how all Redeemed churches are? One shudders at the implication.

Business Is Business

When I first learnt about the story of Pastor Iluyomade, I couldn’t believe the extent of irresponsibility. I seriously expected that he would serve the suspension and return to his duties as soon as he could. Learning that he left to found his own church was disappointing (even, as Nigerians say, nobody appointed me).

But now that I think of it, and I have been through a little more travails in this bitch of a life, I understand it. Not only do I understand it, I support it. Business is business after all. During one of the services, we learn that the church’s charity has donated dialysis machines to a hospital in Edo state. And who ran that charity, His Love Foundation, in its glory days? Pastor Iluyomade himself, special assistant to the General Overseer on Christian Social Responsibility, while pastoring City of David. What a coincidence engineered by the Holy Spirit, you might say.

While writing this letter, I spoke to my friend whose father pastors in RCCG about it, and she informs me that the financial intrigues that go into such appointments are a wonder to behold. In the house of God, I ask. My friend, who is currently dabbling in an atheist phase, says why not. I learn that the pastor who eventually replaced Pastor Iluyomade was a former managing director of the Bank of Industry. Why not, I agree.

Given this, what did you seriously expect the pastor to do? When you lose a stream of income, you search for another. He has bills he’s gotta pay. He’s got mouths he’s gotta feed. What would any serious person expect him to do? Business is business. On an unrelated note, how difficult do you think it is for a camel to walk through the eye of a needle? I suspect that it will be very hard indeed. But we all know that with God, all things are possible.

But Why Does Anyone Sign?

If you are a businessman like me, you would wonder about this problem. Clearly many people — many Christians even — love this deal. In fact, this deal is the most dominant conception of religion in general. But if it is so convoluted, why do so many love it?

Consider a story during my third service. A preacher in his mid-forties tells us a story about a ritualist who did human ritual but didn’t get money. Despite not getting money, this fellow was scared of suffering the repercussions. So he ran to the church, and after just five minutes of prayer, he got well. But now that he was well, he needed money. So he went back to another ritualist to see if they could do something even stronger. This burnt him, and he died.

The moral of this story, I believe, was that Christianity is an exit from all the awfulness of your life. It is somewhere to run to, something to do. Another story in the same sermon drives the point even further. A certain man got into “huge trouble” with HR over a certain unprofessional conduct (what is your serious best guess this conduct might be?), but God somehow brings him out of it, and he suffers no harm whatsoever.

Who else could save you from such diverse troubles? Who else but God? And since we all know this life is precarious beyond measure, isn’t it just nice to have some insurance for whenever the bad times come a-calling? And if these testimonies are true, isn’t the insurance worth it? Even if the sermon is boring, and the church is almost empty, and it requests your money as an offering? Even if? What sort of responsible business person doesn’t get insurance?

Besides, what serious insurance company doesn’t advertise? They even run a news reel in service — nearly twenty minutes of the church reporting its own good news back to itself, in an American accent. Business is business.

Leave a Reply